Jaipur Oil Tank Fire - Can we learn a lesson?
November 10, 2009
The massive oil depot fire that raged for days in Jaipur has
dramatically but tragically illuminated the woefully inadequate fire
service infrastructure in India. While conceding that the Indian Oil
Corporation (IOC) depot fire in Jaipur was prodigious by any standard,
the routine fire accidents that occur on a daily basis reveal the
institutional flaws in the entire fire protection capacity at a
national level.
The Fire ,the subject, its content and its power
of devastation has been taken lightly, while investigations will take
their time ,blame games will continue for ever ,the bottom-line,
a beautifully city completely polluted, precious lives of near and dear
ones gone , besides the time and energy spent on army, police, rescue
missions, etc … call it what you may, but a 1000Cr Rupees( USD
200mill ) sunk and we can see it going in flames on our television sets,
Being
an issue evoking a non-committal response from society and the state in
particular, fire protection has bred over the years a state of apathy
among most Indians. The increasingly execrable conditions under which
the Fire Services (FS) of the country struggle to fork out a sustained
amount of minimum service today are stark but invisible.
The
problem is that, like in any other country, older installations are
often not required to be upgraded to match the current standards, e.g.
if you had bought a car 10 years ago, you are not (necessarily)required
to retrofit it with the latest safety gadgets. The problem is with what
is really necessary = should be mandatory for a safety retrofit and
government authorities struggle with that determination as all
incumbents scream that they cannot afford it.. Personally, I believe
that all oil facilities should always be upgraded if they pose a public
hazard by proximity. Tanks inside IOC facilities sufficiently far away
from other people could be allowed to burn out. This was not the case
in Jaipur and elsewhere in India.
Thus the Oct 23 cabinet
clearance of “a scheme of the Ministry of Home Affairs for
strengthening of fire and emergency services to be implemented at an
estimated cost of Rs.200 crore during the remaining period of the
Eleventh Five Year Plan” is a much-delayed but welcome initiative.
Within
this scheme, fundamental issues like protection of life and property
clearly need to be addressed. Recognizing fire protection as a
fundamental right would benefit every citizen.
Does anyone know
that this is the size of fire safety industry in India, we just sunk
one full industry in no more than a weeks time, but we will never wake
up to the fact that “life is cheap” in India, that we are NOT a Safety
and security conscious country, that we will put our personal interest
before our safety, health and security, and that we consider spending
money on safety equipment, training and education of people as an
expense rather than investment. Strange our ways of country, we always
view disaster as something which will never happen to us, because God
is with us.
After having spending so many years in this industry
I sometimes feel that nothing can change our thinking in India, but
nevertheless I don't loose hope, HOPE, that’s the only silver
lining.... the only way to bring about a radical change is to teach our
kids the priorities of life … first .Safety and health and then
anything else, I am happy that institutions like Honeywell Life Safety
& Fire Safety Association Of India is deeply involved in school
program activities like teaching basics of life safety when impacted
with fire threatening conditions, I HOPE some day we can change our
thinking…
With India aiming to be among the ranks of developed
nations by 2020, heavy investment in R&D and the establishment of
test laboratories conforming to national and international fire
standards are a pre-requisite. Simultaneously, the insurance rules for
fire protection for life, property, crops, manufacturing facilities and
other assets clearly need to be instituted, as insurance remains a key
multiplier for all related activities — thereby enabling them to become
self-sustaining and reducing dependence on the government.
India’s
home secretary recently stated at a business seminar that $6 billion
has been earmarked for strengthening homeland security. With homeland
security thus engaging national attention in such a major way, fire
protection can and must be developed as a key integral component of
this much-needed but largely ignored national effort. The next big fire
as in Jaipur and elsewhere of 2010 must see India better prepared.
By:
Mr Arun Khazanchi FSAI – Executive Board Member
|